Accounting for Profit for Breach of Contract. Theory and by Katy Barnett

By Katy Barnett

This publication defends the view that an award of an account of earnings (or 'disgorgement damages') for breach of agreement will occasionally be justifiable, and it matches in the orthodox rules and circumstances in agreement legislation. besides the fact that, there's a few confusion as to while such an award will be made. the ethical bases for disgorgement damages are deterrence and punishment, which form the treatment in vital methods. Courts also are thinking about vindication of the claimant's functionality curiosity, and it's pivotal that the claimant can procure a alternative functionality through an award of damages or particular aid. The publication argues that disgorgement damages could be to be had in different types of case: 'second sale' circumstances, the place the defendant breaches his agreement with the claimant to make a extra ecocnomic agreement with a 3rd occasion; and 'agency challenge' situations, the place the defendant supplies the claimant he'll no longer do a definite factor, and the claimant reveals it tough to oversee the functionality. furthermore, disgorgement could be complete or partial, and 'reasonable price damages' for breach of agreement are most sensible understood as partial disgorgement instead of 'restitutionary damages.' Equitable bars to reduction must also be followed in terms of disgorgement damages, as may still allowances for ability and energy. Accounting for revenue for Breach of agreement might be of curiosity to agreement and advertisement legal professionals, and it'll be specifically helpful to an individual with an curiosity in agreement treatments and restitution. The e-book attracts on case legislation in a few universal legislations jurisdictions, essentially England, Wales, and Australia. (Series: Hart stories in deepest legislations)

Show description

Read or Download Accounting for Profit for Breach of Contract. Theory and Practice PDF

Best administrative law books

The protection of historic properties : a comparative study of administrative policies

This publication is an creation to the security of old homes by way of public enterprises in 3 very various felony platforms - the USA, the uk and Spain - in addition to analysing overseas efforts to guard old historical past. it isn't meant as a complete learn of any of the criminal platforms, yet quite as a device to offer the reader the opportunity to check the felony options utilized in every one various administrative procedure.

Smith and Keenan's Company Law

Smith and Keenan's corporation legislation is a transparent, finished and sensible consultant to corporation legislation perfect for these trying to know how corporation legislation works in actual lifestyles context. Authoritative and but obtainable, the recent variation has been revised and rewritten to completely contain the firms Act 2006 and offers a certainly specified consultant for undergraduates learning the topic for the 1st time.

Applying Ecological Principles to Land Management

This quantity applies ecological rules and directions to appreciate earlier and present land use and land administration; and extra importantly, endeavors to advertise extra ecologically sound techniques to destiny land use and administration judgements. the amount comprises case experiences from a wide selection of disciplines and views.

Labour Law

Development on their profitable circumstances and fabrics e-book, Collins, Ewing and McColgan current a completely restructured and freshly written new textbook on employment legislation. finished and fascinating, it combines precise research and remark at the legislations with brief contextual extracts to completely equip the labour legislations pupil.

Additional info for Accounting for Profit for Breach of Contract. Theory and Practice

Example text

67 ibid 149–54. 68 ibid 150–54. 69 In Ben McFarlane’s terminology, this could be said to be an equitable proprietary right, ie a ‘right to a right’. See B McFarlane, The Structure of Property Law (Oxford, Hart Publishing, 2008). 22 Rationales Behind Disgorgement Damages well as an ownership right in any action of Bert’s that is incompatible with A. Consequently, where A is a particular action and where Bert’s doing B is incompatible with his doing A, then Alice is entitled by way of damages to any profits realized by Bert as a result of doing B.

4 Only two of the rationales listed above convincingly provide a moral justification for full disgorgement damages: namely, deterrence and retribution. A compensatory analysis is perhaps more convincing for Wrotham Park damages, but as such damages are classified as ‘partial disgorgement’ in my scheme, deterrence and retribution provide the best justifications. Deterrence is the central justification behind disgorgement damages. 5 At present, when compensatory damages are inadequate to protect the claimant’s performance interest and specific relief, obtainable when the breach first occurred, is no longer available, a defendant has no incentive to stop him from breaching and leaving the claimant without a substitute performance.

7 8 14 Rationales Behind Disgorgement Damages nature, I argue that it is more coherent in a contractual context to see it as gainbased relief that is grounded in deterrence and retribution. In this chapter, I will first consider the supposed compensatory rationale and suggest that it is not an appropriate justification for disgorgement damages. I will then consider, successively, the specific operation of deterrence and retribution. 15 The nature of the right gained under a contract will be discussed in detail in the section dealing with substitutive compensation.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.99 of 5 – based on 36 votes